Everything on model trains, model railroads, model railways, locomotives, model train layouts, scenery, wiring, DCC and more. Enjoy the world's best hobby... model railroading!

Plastic or Metal Wheels?

James asks this question:

“I want to change some of my rolling stock wheels from plastic to metal. What size 33/36 is the best?”

Share on FacebookEmail this to someoneTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInShare on StumbleUponShare on Google+Share This Post

7 Responses to Plastic or Metal Wheels?

  • Anton says:

    33 or 36 or maybe even 28 depends on rolling stock. Most US passenger cars have 36″ wheels. Exceptions are LRC (Light-Rapid-Comfortable) cars with 28″ wheels, mostly operated by VIA RAIL in Canada. 3-level autoracks ride on 28″ wheels. Most transition era freight equipment has 33″ wheels while many modern freight cars, especially tankcars have 36″. Heavy duty 100 ton hoppers as well as intermediate trucks on articulated indermodal trains – 38″. Also 38″ is suitable for replacing wheels with deep “pizza cutter” flanges on most European passenger cars that have 950mm wheels. Some EU sleeping cars with 1000mm wheels – 40″ replacement is the closest one. EU yard locomotives often have 1050mm wheels where 42″ substitute would be the closest. And some mainline EU locomotives – 1150mm wheels (close to 45″). Most EU locomotives are the thing I struggle with: they have 1250mm wheels or 49.2″. And in North America I cannot find wheels with proper flanges of that diameter.

    This is in general but to know exactly the best replacement in your case I have to see trains you are looking to replace wheels on.

    Hope this helps.

  • Newman Atkinson says:

    James, Replacement wheels Metal is always the best but that is something that can cost a little more but even if you replace with plastic wheels with metal axles you are gaining on performance. Metal wheels with metal axles are the best as far as getting less drag on your train. Plastic with metal axles will help immensely if you can do that Plastic wheels with plastic axles are a drag all the way and especially as they get older the plastic will get rough and increase the drag.
    Take a similar car about the same weight on the same grade hill and you will find the performance down the hill increase with the metal axles and metal wheels. The diameter of the wheels also can be problems with your car height especially if they have been replaced before with the wrong size wheels. The hill test will make a believer out of you. Some clubs require only metal wheels with metal axles. Resistors can be installed across the wheel set that helps detect if cars are on a section of track .
    It is not required to change them but as you upgrade your equipment take the time to upgrade toward the metal wheels. Your performance will greatly improve. I just do this as I pull the cars in for maintenance. It would be expensive to do your whole fleet at once. from Newman

  • If you’re modeling the transition era, most freight cars used 33″ wheels. Many prewar cars had ribbed back wheels. Passenger cars had 36″ wheels. I was told by a manufacturer of HO wheels that performance can be improved by using metal axles with plastic sideframes and plastic axles (delrin) with metal sideframes. Seems correct. Metal wheels don’t accumulate the gunk that plastic wheels do. Hope this helps.

  • Tony van Geijlswijk says:

    Any good shops where I can buy metal wheels in big quantities?
    anywhere in the world, I am in the Netherlands but do US N scale trains and have 55 type rail.

    Tony

    • Newman Atkinson says:

      Tony, Hobby Town USA has 33 inch ,and 36 inch metal sets usually 12 in a pack ribbed and straight. Sometimes rusted but usually Black. in HO I know they have N scale and I will be stopping at one of their stores Sunday evening after the Noblesville Train Show Sunday and I can look for you. Kadee has wheel sets in HO, Wheel axles in HO I will have to look up on their webb site KADEE.com to check for N scale WHere quantity is then I would be looking at KADEE Webb site but not sure if they have big quantities there
      from Newman Atkinson

      • Newman Atkinson says:

        Tony, I just got back from the Noblesville Train Show near Indianapolis Indiana USA today But after the show we stopped in a Hobby Shop near there and I asked about your wheels you are looking for.
        Yes they have a couple different wheels in metal that are suppose to be 33 inch wheels. Not sure if they have 36 inch wheels for passenger cars but probably do. They are from the Manufacturer of Fox Valley Models and are handled by Hobby Town USA.
        There are 2 different axles lengths so you may need to do some measuring before you order any. They come in packs of 12 and you might want also want to do the bulk of 40 The MFG Fox Valey have them in a Bulk of 40 and could be better for you with shipping I would think. Here is Hobby Town USA contact info: Bulk would have to be ordered.
        This is the store about an hour and a half from me but it is a chain of stores all over the USA.

        HOBBYTOWN USA
        Dan Terhune Manager
        8326 Castleton Corner Drive
        Indianapolis, Indiana 46250

        Phone is: area code 317-845-4106 (not sure of the country code you would need)
        Fax is 317-845-4209
        Web site: hobbytown.com

        The wheel sets are from FOX Valley Model Railroad Supply But look up Fox Valley N scale or something like that. You should be able to get them in Bulk of 40 if you want.
        Hobby Town said they ship all over the world. Well you know what I know now Good Luck from Newman Atkinson

  • donj1044 says:

    Use 33 inch wheels.for freight cars!!!
    A good hobby shop manager should have told you this when you purchased them.
    36 inch wheels are for passenger cars etc
    good luck to you
    Don

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

Add a photo or image related to your comment (JPEG only)

Reader Poll #1

On your layout - How important is having more SCENIC REALISM compared to having more TRACK / OPERATION? Select your personal preference by choosing a number from 1 to 10.

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Reader Poll #2

On your layout - How important is having more SWITCHING compared to having more MAINLINE RUNNING? Select your personal preference by choosing a number from 1 to 10.

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Scenery Techniques Explained

A Great Christmas Gift!

N Scale Track Plans

Watch Video

Learn About DCC

Use Tiny Railroad Micro Controllers



A micro controller is basically a small programmable computer device to help the model railroader “make things operate.” It is clever way to realistically replicate the movements, actions and functions you are likely to see on a full size railroad.

Free Catalog

NEW TO MODEL TRAINS?

Watch These Club Videos

Club members access helpful new resources each month: diagrams, video tutorials, articles, track plans and more. Watch the tour videos here.

Bringing Your Railroad To Life!

SUBMIT YOUR QUESTION

Submit Your Model Railroading Questions!

Before you submit your model railroading question please add some feedback, answers or comments to other postings on this model train blog. What goes around comes around... so if you can help others in the hobby, someone else may help you.

Important - Please add plenty of supporting details to any question you submit (eg. scale, solutions you have already tried etc.) , as the clearest and best questions usually get the best answers. Also, please check your spelling and punctuation as all questions need to be approved by the blog moderator prior to publication. Approved questions are normally published within a week (if not sooner).

Submit your model train questions here.

Model Train Help Ebook

Scenery & Layout Ideas

Share With Friends

 

Submit Your Article

Would you like to write an article and have it published?

Preference will be given to articles that help others progress in the hobby, maybe suggesting an idea for their layout, a quick tip or two... or perhaps a little bit of good advice based on your model railroading experiences.

We are all in this hobby together, so the more we can do to share ideas and help each other, the better.

Submit Your Article Here

It’s YOUR Railroad!

Your rolling stock and locomotives might actually be the center of attention on your layout, but the scenic features that surround and envelop your layout is what's likely to make your train setup stand proud of the rest. Your selection of scenery and structures will add an element of customization that will make your railroad truly unique.



Scenery, structures, and fine detailing is a fundamental aspect of any good model railroad, particularly if it is intended to replicate a true-to-life railroading scene. How realistic or authentic you make your railroad is entirely up to you... and you alone.

Some enthusiasts like to replicate every tiny detail so as to accurately depict, in every aspect, a miniaturized version of a real life scene.

Others in this hobby adopt a more "free-style" approach and choose to mix and match accessories and features they personally prefer. Even though the purist will possibly be unimpressed with unrealistic or out of context elements, it is YOUR railroad layout so you can make it anything you personally want!

Model Railroading Blog Archive