Everything on model trains, model railroads, model railways, locomotives, model train layouts, scenery, wiring, DCC and more. Enjoy the world's best hobby... model railroading!

Designing an Oval Helix

Chip is hoping a reader might be able to supply some advice:

“I plan on building a helix for my HO layout. However, instead of building it circular, I am going to build it in an oval. Has anyone got a formula or a plan that would help me plan out what I need to do?”

9 Responses to Designing an Oval Helix

  • Davesays:

    I would think you could design the helix using 2 segments and then spit the helix and insert appropriate straight sections to connect the two halves.

  • Leonsays:

    Building a helix is a lot of work and building an oval helix is that much worse as you will have many many more points of friction and pulling the consist up the helix to reach the top.

    Think of it this way; your consist is going to be pulling out all its slack as it climbs and the lateral forces on a properly weighted locomotive and a string of cars are going to be pulling on the cars behind them on the climb and the need to cross each oval will put more stress on the couplers as they will quickly revert from an oval to a straight portion and the cars following will have to do the same as the cars ahead of them.

    You have to think in terms of a derailment as a long consist will or could break and derail and the consist below the point of separation is going on a wild ride and if you have a train waiting to climb its going to get hit and derail that train too.

    A switchback will cause fewer problems and will cost you less time and money to build it.
    A multi engine consist will handle a 4 percent grade.as long as you have enough amperage to run at least 2 or 3 locomotives. .

    You could have a shorter tail track and make multiple switching moves with a dedicated set of railway locomotives and 2 yard track sidings one at the top and one at the bottom.

    Just like the real railroads any curvature will cause wear and require the locomotives to work harder where a linear track even with a grade will work much better as long as there is adequate adhesion.

    A switchback will be easier to build as all the track sections are linear. you just have to be sure the grades are done correctly to allow the tail

    Arthur Mellon Wellington said it best in his book “On The Placement Of Railroads”

    “A switchback is the most efficient way to climb a mountain”.

    Properly done it can look beautiful with modern construction methods using modeled parts of sheet piling and concrete retaining walls and concrete snow sheds along the route ..

  • Rich Aubelsays:

    Building an oval helix serves no purpose at all since the grade of the helix is determined by the short dimension of the oval. The vertical spacing of the track is the critical factor in determining the grade so the extra length on the long oval side doesn’t change anything on the helix calculations. The best thing to do would be to build a circular helix and use the leftover space for other track or scenery, or as has been previously suggested, build it as a regular helix with straight sections between the curves.

  • Ian Bell (Hawthorn Valley Railway)says:

    Try this link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFMU1i1Fr-g&t=14s

    The gentlemen concerned on this video will help you as he designed his own helix, which is a LOOOONNNNNGGG oval helix. I tried to find the video of the start of it, but could not find it so I added this one for you.

    He can probably give you the link for when he first deigned.

    Have fun

  • David Stokessays:

    Dave,
    Firstly there appears to be some confusion among responders so I’ll interpret your question before answering it. You want to build an oval helix – that is, the grade to be constant along to whole length of the track, not two end curves horizontal and a series of rmps joining them as appears to have been the guys mindpictures.

    I would use the circular helix formula to get a clear picture of what you’re dealing with and then stretch it. The number of layers would not change but the longer, straight (ish) sides would have slightly less gradient, which would lessen the strain on locos and allow longer trains. Hope that helps.

  • donj1044says:

    It is lengthy but this should do for you.
    Use This FREE Model Railroad
    Helix Design Calculator To Avoid Frustrating Construction Mistakes! http://www.modelbuildings.org/free-helix-design-calculator.html
    This page includes a lot of helpful information and sketches to assist you with planning construction of a helix for your model railroad layout.
    Firstly, here is a tool to help you with important measurements including the track radius and required headroom. This helix calculator will do most of the mentally difficult calculations for you with a simple click of your mouse.
    Enter the details and it will calculate measurements for percent grade, ring diameter, number of rings needed, along with the quantity of material needed. Simply enter the numbers you want and adjust them until you obtain results that will be suitable for what you want to construct.
    How to Use This Calculator For Planning and
    Constructing a Model Railroad Helix
    IMPORTANT: Before entering any numbers we recommend you read the
    “INPUT GUIDE” below this calculator. It explains how to input the correct numbers.
    HELIX CALCULATOR
    A. Enter Track Radius (inches)
    from 4 to 100
    B. Enter greatest height of train (inches)
    from .5 to 50
    C. Enter total height to climb (inches)
    from 3 to 96
    D. Enter width of ring (inches)
    from 1 to 24
    E. Select segments per layer (a whole number)
    from 2 to 8*

    F. Ring diameter is
    inches
    G. Vertical distance between rings is
    inches between rings including 1/2″ thickness of ring
    H. Ring circumference is
    inches per each ring
    I. Grade is
    %
    J. Rings needed is
    rings
    K. Length each segment (based on segments in E)
    inches
    L. Total material length is
    inches.
    M. Total Material Required
    sq.ft.

    Helix Calculator INPUT GUIDE
    • A. Enter the track radius (inches): MUST BE BETWEEN 4 and 100
    This is the radius of the curved track you plan to use.
    • B. Enter the greatest height of train (inches): MUST BE BETWEEN .5 and 50
    This is the height of the tallest loco (or fully laden rolling stock) you will run on the helix.
    • C. Enter the total height to climb (inches): MUST BE BETWEEN 3 and 96
    This is the distance (in inches) between the track entry and exit (bottom and top) of the helix.
    • D. Enter the width of ring (inches): MUST BE BETWEEN 1 and 24
    This is how wide the rings are to carry the track.
    • E. Select the segments per layer (a whole number): MUST BE BETWEEN 2 and 8 (* NO Decimal Values)
    This is how many pieces of material you want to use to make one complete ring.

    Understanding The Results

    • F. Ring diameter is in inches. The track radius x 2 + 4″
    • G. Vertical distance between rings is the inches between the rings with a 1/2″ allowance for the thickness of ring material (plywood). The train height you entered (B) + 1/2″ track height + 1/2″ for layer material thickness.
    • H. Ring circumference is inches of each ring. The ring diameter you entered (F) x 3.14
    • I. Grade is a %. A bigger track radius can be entered if the grade is too steep
    • J. The number of rings needed. The total height to climb (C) divided by the vertical distance between the rings (G)
    • K. Each segment length in inches based on what you selected (E). The ring circumference (H), divided by the segments per layer (E).
    • L. Total material length is in inches. The quantity of rings needed(J) x ring circumference (H).
    • M. Total material required in sq ft. Total material length (L) x ring width (D), divided by 144 (a square foot), and based on a 32 sq. ft. sheet of plywood
    What is a helix?

    A helix is like a ‘spiral-staircase’ for trains, because it enables them to climb in height from one level on a model railroad layout to another in the smallest space possible. The trains basically go around in circles gradually climbing higher and higher with each 360 degree rotation (circumference).
    A helix is simply a winding gradient (slope or grade) that goes around in circles. Helix’s can be very effective visually and very efficient from a space-saving point of view.
    This helix on display at a train show has a 3.5% grade and 158 feet of double track.
    However, figuring out the measurements and material requirements can be a bit baffling at first. The design not only needs to work geometrically, but the locomotives and cars need to be able to navigate the various levels without derailing and crashing from a great height. The locomotives need to be powerful enough to cope with both the climb and descent.
    The above calculator will help you calculate the required measurements and dimensions, and also help you understand how they interact when designing a helix.
    How does a helix work?
    There are three keys to a success helix design: RISE, RUN and RADIUS. Getting the measurements right for these three values is the critical part of designing a workable helix. When you use the free helix calculator (above), you will see that changing any one of these measurements will impact on all other measurements. This is why this calculator is so handy; you can fiddle around with it until you get the dimensions you require. As an example; the track radius will influence the required “RUN” for a helix ring.
    It doesn’t matter whether you have 100 inches of track climbing a grade in a straight line, or whether that same track goes around 360 degrees in a circle, it is still 100 inches of track. I say that because, when the track goes around in circles it is easy to get confused. So the length of the track (whether it’s in a straight line or in a circle), will determine the grade (gradient) of the climb.
    The ring radius is measured from the centre of the circle. It is half the diameter (width) of the complete circle.
    The radius of each helix ring will depend on the track radius. However; just because you are using 18” radius track, it doesn’t mean the radius of the helix rings is also 18”. Track radius is actually measured from the center of the ties, and not from the outer edge of the track. For this reason the radius of each ring might need to be around 20” to 22”. This is because you will need a safety margin on each side of the track so the trains are not running along the edge.
    How do you calculate the RUN or length of a helix ring?
    Put simply, the RUN or length is the circumference of the circle, but to calculate that you first need to know the radius and diameter. Fortunately, that is usually the easiest to work out.
    The circle diameter is twice the radius, so if the circle made from 22 inch radius segments, then the diameter (circle width) will be 44 inches. When you know the circle diameter it is then possible to work out the circumference of the circle (the run on the helix ring).
    Here’s the formula to calculate the circumference around the outer edge of the circle.

    Using the above formula you simply multiply the (known) diameter by the pi (π ) value which is 3.14. The result is the (unknown) circumference.
    As an example; if the diameter is 44” the circumference would be 138” (44 inches x 3.14). The real answer is actually 138.16 inches, but 138 inches is close enough.
    So, the helix ring could need to be a fraction over 138 inches. Converted this calculates out at 11 feet 6 inches (approx). Therefore each ring will need around 11 feet 6 inches of materials and 44 inches of space.
    How do you calculate the RISE or headroom of a helix ring?
    Use the free railroad grade calculator on this website to calculate the RISE or grade.
    If the tallest locomotive or piece of loaded rolling stock is 2 ½” tall, then it would make sense to allow at least a 3” headroom or rise. So the separation (headroom) between each ring would be 3 inches.

    I haven’t got room to show you a grade on 100 inches of track (the web page is too narrow) so I’ve scaled the diagram down. That’s why the 2 inch rise looks smaller in the drawing below.

    The vertical distance (headroom) between each ring needs to include a clearance for your tallest train (maybe 2 1/2 inches high) plus an allowance for the rails height (1/2″), and ply ring base (1/2″). So the vertical distance between the rings could be 3 1/2 inches based on this example. However, some layouts do skimp a little with amount of headroom, so it is really over to you to decide what is best in your situation, and how much difference saving a 1/4 inch or 1/2 inch might make to the overall dimensions, steepness, access, and smooth operation of the helix.
    Using the earlier measurements, the RUN is 138 inches. The ring separation is to be 3”, but will the locomotives be capable of hauling trains up that grade? The answer will depend on the length of run. The shorter the run – the steeper the grade.
    So using the free grade calculator mentioned above; a 138 inch run that rises 3 inches gives a grade of 2.17% which is not too steep.
    If you want the grade to be exactly 2% with the same rise of 3 inches, then here’s how to calculate the length of run.
    That tells us what our grade will be when we know the run and the rise. But suppose we want to figure it the other way. Suppose we want a 2% grade exactly, with a 3” rise? How long a run will we need to hit the 2%? To calculate this you need to work out what number divided into 3 inches equals 2%. Simply divide 3 inches by 0.02 (this is the same as 2%) and the answer is 150 inches.
    The diameter can be therefore calculated like so: Circumference 150” = Diameter x 3.14. That’s the same as 150”/3.14 = 47.77” diameter (call it 48 inches). This then makes the radius 24 inches (half 48 inches).
    What is the vertical distance for a model railroad helix design?
    Obviously the smaller the grade the more rings you might need in your helix for the train the climb to the top or get back down again. That’s where the vertical distance is so important. If it’s too high, the required number of helix rings or the ring diameter might prove impractical. The vertical distance is a straight line from the top to bottom, not the track length around the rings from top to bottom.
    As an example; a helix with a vertical distance of 36 inches with a 2 inch rise would need 18 rings, whereas only 9 rings would be needed if the rise was 4 inches. So a gentler grade would require more rings (and more materials).
    Another factor to consider is the type and thickness of material you choose to build your helix. If you choose ½ inch plywood, as an example, you would need to add ½ inch headroom to determine the vertical spacing between the rings.
    Also consider how many rings you can cut from your sheet of ply and how you can get the most from each sheet with minimum wastage. A standard plywood sheet measures 48” x 96” (4ft x 8ft). With a ring radius of 48” and a ring width of 6”, then you would only be able to cut two complete 6” wide rings, and end up with 2 big circles with a lot of wastage from the 4ft x 8ft plywood sheet.

    The better option is to cut the rings into sections which you could join together end-to-end to complete each ring.
    Another factor to consider is the minimum acceptable track curve radius for the scale you are working in. In HO scale 18 inches is considered by many to be the minimum (some say 15”), but it also depends on the type of rolling stock you are operating.
    So as you will have gathered by now, there are numerous inter-related factors that need to be considered when designing and constructing a model railroad helix.

  • Dhyansays:

    If you are a bit handy with woodworking tools, then it should not be a problem. What you need are multiple planks of wood cut into J shapes, width depends on how many tracks you wish to lay on the helix. Then you flip half of the planks to the left, arrange them so that the longer arm of the J touches the shorter arm of the J of the other half and two Js, one next to the other will form a perfect oval. Then just stack them up, depending on the height you wish to achieve, drill holes at close intervals, take long bolts and just screw everything onto a base (each stack of Js has its own base). Make sure that each plank had a nut and washer under and above the plank so that you can adjust the gradient. Bring them together, bolt the bases together, and you have your helix. See photo of my oval helix to get some idea.

    Good luck and have fun with your hobby.

  • Chipsays:

    Thanks everyone for your reply, especially donj1044 for such a thorough explanation and guide. I will take everyone’s advice into account as I move forward in my build.

  • Tephansays:

    Be sure to let us know of your results.

    Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Add a photo or image related to your comment (JPEG only)

Everything DCC

Free Catalog

Use Tiny Railroad Micro Controllers



A micro controller is basically a small programmable computer device to help the model railroader “make things operate.” It is clever way to realistically replicate the movements, actions and functions you are likely to see on a full size railroad.

SUBMIT YOUR QUESTION

Submit Your Model Railroading Questions!

Before you submit your model railroading question please add some feedback, answers or comments to other postings on this model train blog. What goes around comes around... so if you can help others in the hobby, someone else may help you.

Important - Please add plenty of supporting details to any question you submit (eg. scale, solutions you have already tried etc.) , as the clearest and best questions usually get the best answers. Also, please check your spelling and punctuation as all questions need to be approved by the blog moderator prior to publication. Approved questions are normally published within a week (if not sooner).

Submit your model train questions here.

Watch These Club Videos

Club members access helpful new resources each month: diagrams, video tutorials, articles, track plans and more. Watch the tour videos here.

NEW TO MODEL TRAINS?

HO TRACK PLANS

N Scale Track Plans

Watch Video

Model Train Help Ebook

Scenery Techniques Explained

Bringing Your Railroad To Life!

Scenery & Layout Ideas

Share With Friends

 

Submit Your Article

Would you like to write an article and have it published?

Preference will be given to articles that help others progress in the hobby, maybe suggesting an idea for their layout, a quick tip or two... or perhaps a little bit of good advice based on your model railroading experiences.

We are all in this hobby together, so the more we can do to share ideas and help each other, the better.

Submit Your Article Here

It’s YOUR Railroad!

Your rolling stock and locomotives might actually be the center of attention on your layout, but the scenic features that surround and envelop your layout is what's likely to make your train setup stand proud of the rest. Your selection of scenery and structures will add an element of customization that will make your railroad truly unique.



Scenery, structures, and fine detailing is a fundamental aspect of any good model railroad, particularly if it is intended to replicate a true-to-life railroading scene. How realistic or authentic you make your railroad is entirely up to you... and you alone.

Some enthusiasts like to replicate every tiny detail so as to accurately depict, in every aspect, a miniaturized version of a real life scene.

Others in this hobby adopt a more "free-style" approach and choose to mix and match accessories and features they personally prefer. Even though the purist will possibly be unimpressed with unrealistic or out of context elements, it is YOUR railroad layout so you can make it anything you personally want!

Model Railroading Blog Archive

Reader Poll

Sorry, there are no polls available at the moment.